Review · USA

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl

★ 4.5 · 24 reviews From $48 Operated by The Original Ghost Tour · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

Williamsburg’s darkest stories are not about ghosts. They are about real murders, crime, and hatred, told during an evening walk through the old city. This three-hour tour mixes true crime with drinks at three local establishments, giving you a change of pace every 30 minutes or so.

I like the unusual subject, since most Williamsburg tours focus on colonial buildings, political history, or ghost tales. I also like the built-in pauses for a beer, wine, or another bar choice, plus the chance to hear guides such as Randy and Heather bring their own knowledge of the area to the walk. The main caution is the amount of walking: about 90 minutes of the experience takes place outdoors, and one participant found it much more demanding than expected.

Key things to know before booking

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - Key things to know before booking

  • Three drinks are included: You receive one alcoholic beverage at each of the three stops, with the choice coming from that establishment’s available drinks.
  • The subject is murder, not ghosts: Expect true crime stories connected to Williamsburg, rather than a standard supernatural tour.
  • The route takes about 90 minutes on foot: The drinks provide breaks, but you should still be comfortable walking through Historic Williamsburg at night.
  • The stops have distinct identities: You visit Precarious Beer Project, the Williamsburg Winery Tasting Room and Wine Bar, and The Hound’s Tale.
  • The tour is private: Only your group participates, which can make it easier to hear the guide and ask questions.
  • The price reflects more than a walk: At $48 per person, you are paying for the guide, three drinks, and a small-group evening activity, but not for a short, quick story session.

Why this Williamsburg tour takes a darker turn

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - Why this Williamsburg tour takes a darker turn

Williamsburg is often presented as a polished colonial town, full of restored buildings and carefully explained public history. This tour takes another route. It focuses on the city’s less comfortable stories, including crimes and murders that took place in and around the old streets.

That focus gives the evening a different mood from a regular sightseeing walk. You are not simply moving from one historic building to another. You are walking between bars while listening to stories about people, conflict, death, and violence.

The tour is described as Williamsburg’s first and only murder-focused tour. The distinction matters because many nighttime walks lean heavily on ghosts, spirits, and legends. Here, the guide’s subject is supposed to be real crime. If you prefer documented or historical wrongdoing to supernatural tales, that is the central reason to choose this experience.

The stories are delivered during the walk, not only while you sit inside a pub. That means the city itself becomes part of the setting. The streets are described as dim and peaceful, a useful contrast to the grim events being discussed.

More Pub Crawls around the USA:

The 7 pm start and private format

The tour begins at 7 pm at 110 S Henry Street and returns to that same meeting point. The evening timing suits the subject. You get the darker atmosphere of Historic Williamsburg without committing to a late-night outing.

The experience lasts about three hours. Each drink stop is scheduled for roughly 30 minutes, leaving about 90 minutes for walking and storytelling. That balance is important. This is not a pub crawl where you spend most of the night seated, and it is not a nonstop history walk either.

Because it is a private activity, only your group takes part. That can be a real advantage if you prefer to ask questions, hear the guide clearly, or keep the pace more personal. It also means the price may feel more reasonable for a small group than for one person booking alone.

You should arrive ready to walk. One low-rated account objected to the amount of walking and did not finish the tour because of a physical ailment. The account also felt that only a few murders had been covered, while the tour operator stated that the full route includes at least 12 murder stories. The practical point is simple: expect a walking tour with several story stops, not three brief crime tales between drinks.

Precarious Beer Project: the opening drink

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - Precarious Beer Project: the opening drink

The first stop is Precarious Beer Project, where you have about 30 minutes for a drink. Your included beverage can be a bar or pub choice, so this first stop gives the evening a relaxed start before the walking portion gathers pace.

Beginning with beer makes sense for a pub crawl. You can settle in, meet your guide, and get a feel for the group before heading into the older streets. The stop also gives you a clear picture of how the tour works: drink, listen, walk, and repeat.

The main benefit is practical. You do not begin with a long stretch of outdoor walking. If you are coming from dinner or arriving in Williamsburg after a day of sightseeing, the first seated stop gives you time to get organized.

Keep in mind that the drink is alcoholic. The tour includes three alcoholic beverages in total, so you should pace yourself across the full evening. If you are looking for a history walk without alcohol, this is not the right format.

Williamsburg Winery Tasting Room: wine in Merchant Square

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - Williamsburg Winery Tasting Room: wine in Merchant Square

The second drink stop is the Williamsburg Winery Tasting Room and Wine Bar in Merchant Square, within the historic area. You spend about 30 minutes here for a glass of wine.

This stop changes the tone of the crawl. The first venue centers on beer, while the winery adds a wine-focused pause in a more historic part of town. That variety keeps the evening from feeling like repeated visits to identical bars.

It also places the drink directly into the setting that makes this tour appealing. You are not only hearing about Williamsburg from a guidebook-style viewpoint. You are stopping in the historic area, then walking through it while listening to stories tied to crime and murder.

The value here depends on your expectations. If you want a formal wine tasting with detailed instruction, the tour description only promises a glass of wine. Think of it as one drink stop within a crime tour, not a standalone winery experience.

The Hound’s Tale: the final pub stop

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - The Hound’s Tale: the final pub stop

The third stop is The Hound’s Tale in Merchants Square. You spend another 30 minutes here and receive a drink of your choice from the pub’s options.

By this point, the final stop acts as both a break and a chance to talk about the stories you have heard. The tour is designed to move between drinks and walking, so this last pause helps prevent the entire evening from becoming one long stretch on foot.

The three establishments also give the experience some local character. Instead of meeting in one bar and remaining there, you see different drinking spots around the area. One positive account praised the establishments as well as the stories, which fits the tour’s basic appeal: you get an evening out, not only a guided lecture.

Still, the focus is not food. No meal is included, and no dinner stop is listed. If you need a full evening meal, eat before or after the tour rather than counting on these visits to provide one.

The walking sections and the murder stories

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - The walking sections and the murder stories

The walking portion lasts about 90 minutes in total. During the route, your guide tells true stories of crime and murder connected to Williamsburg. The tour description promises the city’s most notorious crimes, with some stories taking place in the very old streets around you.

The walking gives the stories a sense of place. You are not hearing crimes as isolated names and dates. You are moving through the town as the guide explains what happened. That connection can make the material easier to remember, especially if you enjoy history best when it is tied to physical locations.

The number of stories matters. One dissatisfied participant expected more murders and reported hearing only three before leaving early. The operator said the complete tour includes at least 12 murder stories, so the amount you hear may depend on completing the route and reaching all the story stops.

I would treat the experience as a guided crime walk with several cases, not as a rapid list of sensational murders. The stories may include broader local history and context between the main crimes. One strong account praised the unique stories and the chance to learn about Williamsburg’s past, which suggests that the tour works best when you want atmosphere and background along with the darker material.

Your guide also affects the evening. Randy received specific praise for making the experience fun, while Heather was praised for her grasp of the area and for leading an enjoyable adventure. Since the tour is private, the guide’s storytelling style may shape the pace and feel of your group’s outing.

What $48 buys you

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - What $48 buys you

The cost is $48 per person. That includes the guide and three alcoholic drinks, one at each stop. It does not include a meal, transportation to the meeting point, or anything beyond the listed drinks.

For a private three-hour activity, the price can be fair if you value the combination of guided stories, walking, and drinks. You are not paying only for a 90-minute talk. You are also receiving three bar visits and a guide who leads the group from one location to the next.

The value is less convincing if you mainly want a short murder presentation. One negative account compared the price with other local tours that cost about half as much. That is a useful warning. Before booking, decide if you want the pub crawl element. If you do not care about the drinks or the social pauses, a less expensive walking tour may suit you better.

The included beverages soften the cost, but they do not erase it. You are paying for an evening package. For couples or small private groups, the format may feel more worthwhile because you get a dedicated guide and several stops. For a solo participant, the per-person price deserves closer thought.

Who will enjoy this best

The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl - Who will enjoy this best

I would recommend this tour to you if you like:

  • True crime connected to real places
  • Evening walks through historic districts
  • A mix of storytelling and social stops
  • Local beer, wine, and pub drinks
  • Private tours where your group sets the conversation
  • History with an unsettling side

It suits adults who want something different from the usual Williamsburg sightseeing route. The tour can also work well for a couple or small group looking for an evening activity that includes both entertainment and local background.

I would hesitate to recommend it if you dislike walking, avoid alcohol, or expect a fast-moving list of shocking crimes. The tour takes three hours, and the walking is not a minor detail. You should also be comfortable hearing about murder and violent events.

The experience is probably not ideal for anyone who needs a tightly structured indoor tour. Most of the crime stories are delivered while moving between the three drink stops, so weather and comfort outdoors matter.

Weather, cancellation, and basic planning

Good weather is required. If poor weather causes a cancellation, you are offered another date or a full refund. The same applies if the minimum number of participants is not met, although you may also be offered a different experience.

For every other cancellation or change, the booking is non-refundable and cannot be amended. That makes it wise to confirm your schedule before paying.

The meeting point is near public transportation, and the activity ends back at the starting point. Most people can participate, but the route still calls for enough mobility to walk for roughly 90 minutes through the historic area. If walking is difficult for you, contact the provider before booking rather than relying on the scheduled drink breaks.

Bring a phone with your mobile ticket available. Wear shoes that you can walk in for the full evening, and remember that the drinks are spread across three hours rather than served all at once.

Should you book The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl?

Book it if you want a private Williamsburg evening built around true crime, local drinking spots, and stories tied to the old city. Randy and Heather have received specific praise for making the experience enjoyable, and the three included drinks give the tour a social rhythm that a standard history walk lacks.

Skip it if you want minimal walking, a lower price, a ghost-centered tour, or a formal meal and tasting. The strongest reason to book is the unusual mix of murder stories and pubs. The strongest reason to hesitate is the time spent outdoors and the possibility that the value will not feel right if you are interested only in the crime material.

For the right audience, $48 buys a full evening rather than a quick haunted stroll. Just arrive ready to walk, pace the drinks, and give the guide time to complete the route.

FAQ

Where does The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl begin?

It begins at 110 S Henry Street, Williamsburg, Virginia 23185.

What time does the tour start?

The tour starts at 7 pm.

How long does the experience last?

The experience lasts approximately three hours.

How many drinks are included?

Three alcoholic beverages are included, with one drink at each of the three pub or bar stops.

Where does the tour end?

The tour ends back at the meeting point.

Can the booking be canceled for a refund?

The experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed for any reason. If poor weather or an insufficient minimum number of participants causes the provider to cancel, you will be offered another date or experience, or a full refund.

More like this

Pub Crawls, compared.

The full Pub Crawls list →
London Small Group Tour of Historical Pubs
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 10,422 reviews· from $40

London Small Group Tour of Historical Pubs

Read our review →
Stonehenge, Windsor Castle and Bath with Pub Lunch in Lacock
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 7,402 reviews· from $123

Stonehenge, Windsor Castle and Bath with Pub Lunch in Lacock

Read our review →
Tokyo Bar Hopping Tour in Shinjuku (All-You-Can-Drink + Dinner)
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 3,587 reviews· from $106

Tokyo Bar Hopping Tour in Shinjuku (All-You-Can-Drink + Dinner)

Read our review →
Prague: Pub Crawl with Unlimited Drinks & 5-floor Club Entry
★★★★★★★★★★4.2· 2,955 reviews· from $40

Prague: Pub Crawl with Unlimited Drinks & 5-floor Club Entry

Read our review →
Pub Crawl Madrid by Mad Party Crew
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 2,526 reviews· from $20

Pub Crawl Madrid by Mad Party Crew

Read our review →
Dublin: Generation Pub Crawl
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 2,457 reviews· from $16

Dublin: Generation Pub Crawl

Read our review →
Adults Only Haunted Pub Crawl in New Orleans
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 2,158 reviews· from $29

Adults Only Haunted Pub Crawl in New Orleans

Read our review →
Amsterdam: Red Light District Pub Crawl with Unlimited Shots
★★★★★★★★★★4.1· 2,130 reviews· from $24

Amsterdam: Red Light District Pub Crawl with Unlimited Shots

Read our review →

Browse the lists this crawl appears in

Scroll to Top

Pick your kind of night

Ghost stories, free shots, or a pint with the history.