Review · NEW YORK CITY
NYC: Boos & Booze Haunted Pub Crawl
Greenwich Village shows you its darker side on this two-hour haunted pub crawl, where murder, duels, Prohibition stories, and a supposedly immortal cat share the bill with local drinks. You begin at One if by Land, Two if by Sea, then walk through eight more locations, including three additional bars.
I like the mix of New York history and easygoing social time, and I like that the stops include real Village landmarks rather than only spooky storytelling. The drawback is clear: drinks cost extra, and the walking route is not suited to people with mobility impairments.
Key points to know before booking

- Start at One if by Land, Two if by Sea: Meet at 17 Barrow Street and look for a guide in a US Ghost Adventures shirt carrying a lantern.
- Three bar stops are included: Drinks are not part of the $30 price, but the stops give you time to mingle.
- Marie’s Crisis Cafe is a highlight: This famous West Village bar is linked to reports of spectral balls of light.
- The route has plenty of New York flavor: See the Friends apartment building, Hangman’s Elm, Jefferson Market Library, and Pirate’s Den.
- Guides make the difference: Becca, Joanna, and Johnathon have each led tours praised for humor, warmth, and strong local storytelling.
- Plan for an adult evening: You must be at least 21, bring ID, wear comfortable shoes, and dress for the weather.
Starting with a ghost at 17 Barrow Street

Your evening begins outside One if by Land, Two if by Sea, at 17 Barrow Street. This starting point sets the tone nicely. The location is tied to a story about a mysterious woman in black who appears near the staircase, so you get your first eerie tale before the group has even settled into its rhythm.
The meeting instructions are simple. Your guide wears a US Ghost Adventures T-shirt and carries a lantern. That detail matters on a busy New York street, where finding the right person can otherwise become a small adventure of its own.
From here, the route winds through Greenwich Village and reaches eight more locations. The tour description identifies three additional bars along the way, but it does not promise a fixed number of drinks or a particular order for every stop. Think of the route as a guided walk with pub breaks, not a bar-hopping package with alcohol included.
The walking format is part of the appeal. You hear a story at one place, then move through the neighborhood to see where the next tale happened. It gives the evening a sense of place that a seated ghost show cannot match.
More Haunted Pub Crawls in the USA:
- Adults Only Haunted Pub Crawl in New Orleans
★ 4.5 · 2,158 reviews - True Crime Pub Crawl – the Original Savannah Murder Tour
★ 5.0 · 1,053 reviews - Spooky Savannah Haunted Pub Crawl
★ 4.5 · 986 reviews
Greenwich Village after dark

Greenwich Village is often linked with art, music, theater, and cafés. This tour points you toward another side of the neighborhood, one shaped by crime, secrecy, punishment, and old supernatural claims.
The stories cover murders, duels, speakeasies, executions, and Prohibition-era mobsters. That range helps keep the evening from becoming one long parade of similar ghost tales. You get social history, crime stories, and local folklore mixed together.
The guide is central to the experience. Johnathon was praised for filling the walk with New York history and plenty of stories, while Becca was described as friendly, funny, engaging, and well prepared. Joanna also received warm praise for making the night feel relaxed and fun. Those comments point to an important practical fact: the route provides the framework, but the guide’s delivery shapes the evening.
The recorded rating is 4.4 from five reviews, with four five-star scores and one three-star score. That is a small sample, so I would treat it as a useful signal rather than a guarantee. The strongest pattern is clear: the guide’s personality and storytelling are the main reasons people enjoy this activity.
The bars are part of the storytelling

You pay $30 per person for the two-hour tour, but drinks are not included. That makes the price reasonable for a guided New York history walk, especially if you value a live guide and several stops. It also means you should set aside extra money for anything you order.
The bar visits are not just filler between haunted locations. They give the group a chance to pause, order a drink, and talk with one another. One five-star account specifically praised the drink stops because they helped the group mingle and get acquainted.
The drink ideas are playful and specific. You might try a Mexican Candy Shot made with GHOST pepper tequila or a Ruby Red Greyhound with Deep Eddy Ruby Red Vodka. These are suggestions rather than included tastings, so check the price before ordering if you are keeping the evening on a strict budget.
You do not need to drink alcohol to appreciate the stories, but the activity is built around pubs and is restricted to people aged 21 and over. If you prefer a quiet historical walk with no bar stops, this is not the right format.
Pirate’s Den and the Prohibition years

Pirate’s Den brings the tour into the era of speakeasies and mobsters. The stop connects the Village to the days when alcohol, secrecy, and organized crime shaped New York nightlife.
That subject fits the crawl well because it gives you a historical explanation for why hidden bars and coded entrances became part of city life. The ghost angle also gains texture here. Instead of hearing only about a spirit in an old building, you get a sense of the people, risks, and choices tied to the place.
The available information does not promise a drink at Pirate’s Den, so do not assume every location is a bar stop. The tour includes three additional bars, but the route also includes non-drinking locations where the guide can focus on the story and the setting.
For me, this is one of the better reasons to book the experience. You are not simply being taken from pub to pub. The stops are linked by themes that explain how Greenwich Village acquired its reputation for secrecy and mischief.
More Pub Crawls around the USA:
- Southern Flavors Food, Pub Crawl, and History Walking Tour
★ 4.5 · 1,623 reviews - Boston Freedom Trail History Pub Crawl Small-Group Tour
★ 5.0 · 996 reviews - All-Inclusive Pub Crawl with Moonshine, Cocktails, and Craft Beer
★ 4.5 · 975 reviews - Creepy Crawl Night-Time Haunted Pub Walking Tour of Savannah’s Historic District
★ 4.5 · 802 reviews
Marie’s Crisis Cafe and the search for strange lights

Marie’s Crisis Cafe is presented as one of New York’s most haunted bars. Here, the guide may tell you about reports of spectral balls of light and invite you to watch for possible evidence.
That wording is important. This is a ghost story and a chance to look for something unusual, not a promise that you will see a spirit. Go with curiosity rather than expectation. You may find the fun in the setting, the story, and the group’s reaction as much as in any unexplained sight.
The bar stop also gives the experience a strong local feel. You are not listening to a generic haunted-house tale in a theater. You are hearing folklore connected to a working Village bar, with the atmosphere of the place adding to the story.
Since drinks cost extra, you can decide for yourself how much to spend at each stop. Ordering one drink can make sense if you want to join the social side of the evening. If you are pacing yourself, you can focus on the guide and save your money for a cocktail that appeals to you.
Hangman’s Elm and Jefferson Market Library

The route also reaches Hangman’s Elm, a location tied to executions. The name alone gives the stop a grim edge, but the value comes from hearing the guide explain how the location fits into the city’s past.
Jefferson Market Library adds another change of mood. Here, you are told to watch for a woman in a blue dress. That image gives the ghost story a clear visual detail, which can make it easier to remember later.
These two locations show why comfortable shoes matter. You are moving between streets, bars, and public landmarks rather than staying in one building. The route is only two hours, but New York pavement, weather, and evening crowds can make a short walk feel longer.
The activity is not suitable for people with mobility impairments. That is not a minor footnote. If stairs, uneven sidewalks, or extended walking are difficult for you, ask the provider about the route before booking, since no adapted option is provided in the information available here.
A stop for the Friends apartment

The tour includes a chance to take selfies outside the apartment building associated with Friends. This is a lighter stop in an itinerary otherwise filled with murder, executions, and ghosts.
It also broadens the appeal of the walk. You do not need to be deeply interested in paranormal stories to enjoy a familiar film and television location. The photo stop gives you something visual and modern to take away from the evening.
The tour does not promise access inside the building, so plan on an exterior photo. That is still useful for anyone who wants a quick pop-culture moment woven into a Greenwich Village walk.
How the guide affects your night

A pub crawl can feel awkward if the guide simply reads facts and sends everyone on their way. Here, the available guide feedback points to a more social style.
Johnathon was praised for his New York history and large store of stories. Becca was described as funny, friendly, engaging, and strong at keeping the group involved. Joanna was singled out for her warm manner and for helping make the evening a blast.
Those details matter because ghost stories depend on timing. A good guide knows when to let a spooky detail sit, when to add a joke, and when to give the group time to order a drink or talk. The tour seems designed for that balance rather than for a solemn lecture.
Still, no guide can control every part of the evening. The energy of the group, the weather, and the mood at each bar will affect your experience. If you want a private tour or a tightly controlled schedule, this public group format may feel less personal.
What to bring and how to prepare

Wear comfortable shoes. You will be walking between locations, and the route is built around moving through Greenwich Village rather than sitting in one place.
Dress for the weather. The activity takes place outdoors as well as inside bars, and there is no promise of shelter during the full route.
Bring an ID card. A copy is accepted according to the activity information. Since the tour is for people aged 21 and over, you should have proof of age with you.
Smoking and video recording are not allowed. You can take selfies at the Friends building, but do not plan on recording the entire tour. That rule also helps keep the experience focused on the guide’s live storytelling.
Transportation is not included. The meeting point is One if by Land, Two if by Sea at 17 Barrow Street, and you need to make your own way there and home again.
Free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the start for a full refund. You can also reserve now and pay later, which helps if your New York schedule is still shifting.
Who should book this Greenwich Village crawl?
I would recommend it to adults who want an informal evening that mixes local history, ghost stories, drinks, and conversation. It suits first-time visitors who want a different look at Greenwich Village, as well as residents who already know the neighborhood but have not heard its darker tales.
It is also a good choice for a small group of friends. The bar stops create natural breaks, and the stories give you plenty to discuss as you walk.
You should think twice if you dislike drinking-centered activities, need a fully accessible route, or prefer a serious history tour with long explanations at each site. The tour is lively and social, not an academic treatment of New York’s past.
Should you book the Boos & Booze Haunted Pub Crawl?
Book it if you want a friendly night walk with real neighborhood stops, a few drinks at your own expense, and ghost stories delivered by a live guide. The $30 price is fair for two hours of guiding and local history, as long as you remember that cocktails and bar purchases are extra.
The best reason to choose it is the combination of settings: One if by Land, Two if by Sea, Pirate’s Den, Marie’s Crisis Cafe, Hangman’s Elm, Jefferson Market Library, and the Friends apartment building. You get spooky folklore, New York crime stories, a pop-culture photo stop, and time to meet people along the way.
Skip it if you want guaranteed paranormal activity. Book it if you enjoy the stories, the atmosphere, and the possibility that an old bar or shadowy building might leave you wondering.
FAQ
Where does the haunted pub crawl meet?
Meet at One if by Land, Two if by Sea, located at 17 Barrow Street, New York, NY 10014.
How do I identify the guide?
Your guide will wear a US Ghost Adventures T-shirt and carry a lantern.
How long does the tour last?
The haunted pub crawl lasts two hours.
Are drinks included in the $30 price?
No. Drinks are not included, so plan to pay separately for cocktails or other orders at the bars.
How many bars does the route visit?
The route includes three additional bars after the starting location. The experience also visits other haunted and historic locations.
Is the tour suitable for people under 21?
No. The activity is not suitable for people under 21.
What should I bring?
Bring comfortable shoes, weather-appropriate clothing, and an ID card. A copy of your ID is accepted.
Can I cancel for a refund?
Yes. You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. You can also reserve now and pay later.
Newly added crawls around the USA
- Wilmington: Boos and Booze Haunted Pub Crawl★ 4.0 · 8 reviews
- Washington DC: Ghosts Boos and Booze Haunted Pub Crawl★ 4.2 · 73 reviews
- Washington, D.C.: History Tour Pub Crawl★ 5.0 · 41 reviews
- Waikiki Ghosts Boos and Booze Haunted Pub Crawl★ 3.9 · 6 reviews
- The Murder Tour and Pub Crawl★ 4.5 · 24 reviews
- DC Ghosts Boos and Booze Haunted Pub Crawl By US Ghost Adventures★ 4.0 · 57 reviews
- Alexandria Ghosts Spirits & Spirits Haunted Pub Crawl★ 5.0 · 26 reviews
- Tampa Terrors Spirits & Spirits Haunted Pub Crawl★ 5.0 · 4 reviews
Haunted Pub Crawls, compared.

True Crime Pub Crawl – the Original Savannah Murder Tour
Read our review →
Creepy Crawl Night-Time Haunted Pub Walking Tour of Savannah’s Historic District
Read our review →
Key West Haunted Pub Crawl and Ghost Tour with Free T-Shirt
Read our review →
Salem Booze and Brews Haunted Pub Crawl by US Ghost Adventures
Read our review →Browse the lists this crawl appears in




