Review · USA

St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl

★ 4.7 · 36 reviews 2 hours From $35 Operated by Revelry Tours · Bookable on GetYourGuide
Book on GetYourGuide →

St. Augustine’s old streets get a grim new meaning on this true crime pub crawl, where each bar stop brings a local murder, disappearance, or unsolved case. You’ll hear about a serial killer who targeted addicts and sex workers, a priest who helped former prisoners, and crimes dating back to 1800.

I like the small group of nine or fewer, which gives the guide room to tell the stories with detail and humor. I also like the short 0.9-mile route through the historic art district, since you get a drink-and-walk evening instead of a long march. The drawback is simple: drinks and food are not included, and the subject matter is often gruesome.

Key points to know

  • Local cases, not generic ghost stories: The tour focuses on named victims, suspects, murders, and unsolved crimes tied to St. Augustine.
  • Four drinking stops or pub settings: The route includes Pizalley’s Chianti Room, Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, Forgotten Tonic, and Prohibition Kitchen, with other downtown stops along the way.
  • A compact walking route: You cover about 0.9 miles through the historic center, including Aviles Street, Saint George Street, and Cathedral Place.
  • Rob has earned strong praise: Recent tours led by Rob have been noted for clear storytelling, humor, and a good mix of history and drinks.
  • Bring identification: This is an adults-only experience for people 21 and older, and you should carry a passport, ID card, or driver’s license.
  • Rain or shine: The tour runs in all weather, so your comfort depends on dressing for the forecast.

A pub crawl built around St. Augustine’s darker side

St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl - A pub crawl built around St. Augustine’s darker side

This is not a standard bar hop with a few spooky one-liners added for atmosphere. The focus is on real crimes tied to St. Augustine, and the guide retraces the locations and circumstances in enough detail to make the old streets feel less decorative and more unsettling.

The experience lasts about two hours and moves through the center of town. You’ll stop for drinks at several pubs, but the guide’s storytelling is the main event. Your ticket covers the guide only, so you pay separately for every beer, cocktail, soft drink, or other beverage.

That arrangement keeps the admission price at $35 per person, which is reasonable if you want a guided history experience and plan to buy only one or two drinks. The value is less attractive if you expect a full food-and-drink package. Think of the price as covering a small-group walking tour with a strong theme, not an evening of included refreshments.

The small group matters. With no more than nine participants, you should be able to hear the guide clearly inside a pub and ask questions without shouting across a large crowd. Recent tours led by Rob were especially praised for humor and strong storytelling, including one rainy evening when the weather added to the mood.

More Haunted Pub Crawls in the USA:

Starting with William Darrell Lindsey at Pizalley’s

St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl - Starting with William Darrell Lindsey at Pizalley’s

The route begins with a meeting at the Ghost City Tours store at 32 Charlotte Street. The tour description also identifies Pizalley’s Chianti Room as the opening pub and meeting setting, so I would check your confirmation carefully before setting out. That small difference in the published meeting details is worth resolving in advance.

Once the group is together, the first major case concerns William Darrell Lindsey, a serial killer active on St. Augustine’s streets from 1983 to 1996. His victims included addicts and sex workers, giving the opening story a modern, street-level connection to the city rather than a distant tale from colonial days.

Pizalley’s Chianti Room gives you a chance to settle in with a drink before the walking begins. The setting is useful at this point because you can get oriented, order what you want, and listen without trying to keep pace on a sidewalk.

Do not expect a light introduction. The material deals with real violence and vulnerable people, and the guide discusses the cases in a direct way. If you prefer mild folklore, old legends, or playful ghost stories, this may be too heavy for your evening.

Casa Reina and the story of Father Rene Robert

St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl - Casa Reina and the story of Father Rene Robert

The next stop is Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, where you can buy another drink and hear about Father Rene Robert. He was known for helping ex-convicts, and his murder gives the tour one of its most striking contrasts: a religious figure devoted to people on the margins becomes the center of a brutal local case.

Casa Reina also changes the rhythm of the night. You move from an initial sit-down story into a second pub setting, where the group can order drinks before heading back into the streets. Food is not included, but the pub stop may appeal if you want to add a meal or snack at your own cost.

The tour is strongest when it connects the crimes to the places around you. Instead of hearing a case in a lecture room, you are walking through the same historic core where the guide says the events unfolded. That makes the stories easier to place, though the old buildings and pleasant pub interiors can create an odd contrast with the subject matter.

You should also be ready for a guide with a sense of humor. Rob’s style has been described as funny as well as detailed, which can help keep a two-hour evening from becoming relentlessly grim. Still, humor will not erase the fact that the stories involve murder and suffering.

Forgotten Tonic and a murder from March 2, 1800

At Forgotten Tonic, the guide turns to a case dated March 2, 1800, on Aviles Street. Aviles Street is identified as the oldest street in the United States, so this part links one of the country’s oldest urban corridors with a murder that took place more than two centuries ago.

This is one of the tour’s best uses of place. You are not simply hearing that an incident happened somewhere in St. Augustine. You are standing along a specific street, listening to the guide explain the setting and the crime while the modern city carries on around you.

Forgotten Tonic is also a practical stop for anyone who wants a more relaxed drink break. You can order a beverage, listen, and let the guide do the work. Since the route is only 0.9 miles, the walk between stops should not dominate the evening, but you will still spend part of the tour outside.

The rain-or-shine policy matters here. Wet cobblestones, umbrellas, and crowded sidewalks can make the walk less comfortable, even if bad weather adds atmosphere. Wear shoes you trust on a short urban walk, and bring rain protection when the forecast calls for it. The tour does not promise a weather cancellation.

Saint George Street and Cathedral Place cases

St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl - Saint George Street and Cathedral Place cases

The route then moves toward Saint George Street and Cathedral Place, right in the center of downtown. These are busy historic areas, so this portion may feel less secluded than the earlier storytelling in a pub. That is part of the point: the guide places disturbing crimes in the middle of familiar public spaces.

You’ll hear about the unsolved murder of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney. An unresolved case can be especially compelling because the story does not end with a neat explanation. The guide’s role here is to lay out the known events and the unanswered questions, allowing you to consider what remains uncertain.

The tour also covers Athalia Ponsell Lindsley, described as a model, Broadway performer, and television hostess who was murdered. Her public career gives the case a wider connection beyond St. Augustine, while the location keeps the story rooted in the city’s streets.

There is another opportunity to purchase drinks around this part of the route. Since the tour includes several bar settings, you can pace yourself rather than ordering something at every stop. That is important for a two-hour walking tour, especially if you want to focus on the stories and make it comfortably to the end.

Ending at Prohibition Kitchen

The final stop is Prohibition Kitchen, a vintage gastropub where the tour ends with more crime stories and a last drink if you choose to buy one. The setting offers a change from the earlier stops and gives the evening a clear finish rather than simply leaving you on a sidewalk after the final case.

The end location may vary, so do not arrange a tight pickup at one exact address unless you have confirmed the final stop with the guide. You finish in the downtown area, but the published information does not guarantee that every group will end at precisely the same place.

I like the way the route ends in a pub. After several serious cases, you have a place to sit, order something, and decide if you want to continue your evening in St. Augustine. You are not rushed into a transport connection or sent away from the historic district.

What the $35 price really covers

At $35, this is priced as a guided small-group activity rather than a basic self-guided pub crawl. You are paying for an English-speaking guide, a planned route, and a sequence of local cases tied to specific streets and bars.

Food and drinks are extra. That is the key budget point. A beer or cocktail at each stop could easily cost more than the tour itself, so decide before you go how many drinks you actually want. You can also choose a nonalcoholic beverage, since the tour description allows for other drinks.

The price is easier to justify if you value the research and narration. It is less compelling if you mainly want to visit the pubs, because you could do that without a ticket. The tour’s benefit is the context: who was involved, where the crimes happened, and how the cases fit into St. Augustine’s long record of violence.

You can cancel up to 24 hours ahead for a full refund, and you can reserve now and pay later. Those terms are useful if your St. Augustine plans are still shifting, though you should still check the exact start time and meeting instructions before the day of the tour.

Who should book this evening walk

I would recommend it to adults who enjoy true crime, local history, and guided storytelling. It suits couples and small groups who want an evening activity with structure but still want time for drinks and conversation.

It is also a good choice if you have already seen the main historic sights and want a different way to understand downtown. The cases take you along Aviles Street, Saint George Street, Cathedral Place, and other central locations, so you get a fresh angle on familiar streets.

This is not a good match for children or anyone under 21. It is also not ideal if you dislike graphic crime stories, need a quiet evening, or want your food and drinks included in the ticket.

The group size and guide style can shape the experience. Rob has received especially strong praise for combining detailed stories with humor, and a small group can make that style work well. Since guides can vary, treat Rob’s presence as a possibility rather than a guarantee unless your booking confirms it.

Practical advice before you go

Arrive with a government-issued ID. The activity is for people 21 and older, and the instructions list a passport, ID card, or driver’s license as acceptable items to bring.

Plan for walking, even though the route is short. The distance is about 0.9 miles, but you may be standing between stops and moving through historic streets. Comfortable footwear and weather-ready clothing will make the night easier.

The tour is in English, and video recording is not allowed. You can listen, take in the surroundings, and perhaps make brief personal notes, but do not plan to film the guide’s stories.

Most important, confirm the meeting point. The official meeting information gives the Ghost City Tours store at 32 Charlotte Street, while the route description names Pizalley’s Chianti Room as the first stop. Check your confirmation so you do not begin the evening at the wrong end of town.

Should you book the Blood on the Cobblestones crawl?

Book it if you want real local crime cases, a short historic-center walk, and a guide-led evening built around pubs rather than a standard sightseeing tour. The $35 fee is fair for a small group and two hours of detailed narration, but your total cost will rise with each drink and any food you order.

Skip it if you want gentle ghost stories or a family activity. For the right audience, the mix of St. Augustine streets, old crimes, modern cases, and pub stops makes this an unusual way to spend an evening. Just bring identification, dress for rain or shine, and confirm the starting instructions before you go.

FAQ

How long does the St. Augustine true crime pub crawl last?

The tour lasts two hours.

How far do you walk?

The route covers about 0.9 miles through St. Augustine’s historic center.

What is the price?

The listed price is $35 per person.

Are drinks included?

No. Food and drinks are not included, so you purchase beverages separately at the pubs.

Is the tour only for people over 21?

Yes. The activity is not suitable for anyone under 21.

What identification should I bring?

Bring a passport, ID card, or driver’s license.

What language is the tour in?

The tour is conducted in English.

Where does the tour meet?

The stated meeting point is the Ghost City Tours store at 32 Charlotte Street. The route description also names Pizalley’s Chianti Room as the initial pub, so confirm the exact instructions before arrival.

Does the tour run in bad weather?

Yes. The tour takes place rain or shine.

Can I record the tour?

No. Video recording is not allowed.

More like this

Haunted Pub Crawls, compared.

The full Haunted Pub Crawls list →
Adults Only Haunted Pub Crawl in New Orleans
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 2,158 reviews· from $29

Adults Only Haunted Pub Crawl in New Orleans

Read our review →
Spooky Savannah Haunted Pub Crawl
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 986 reviews· from $33

Spooky Savannah Haunted Pub Crawl

Read our review →
Savannah Haunted Pub Crawl Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 695 reviews· from $34

Savannah Haunted Pub Crawl Walking Tour

Read our review →
Key West Haunted Pub Crawl and Ghost Tour with Free T-Shirt
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 549 reviews· from $32

Key West Haunted Pub Crawl and Ghost Tour with Free T-Shirt

Read our review →
Salem Booze and Brews Haunted Pub Crawl by US Ghost Adventures
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 413 reviews· from $36

Salem Booze and Brews Haunted Pub Crawl by US Ghost Adventures

Read our review →
Salem: Boos and Brews Haunted Pub Crawl
★★★★★★★★★★4.1· 411 reviews· from $30

Salem: Boos and Brews Haunted Pub Crawl

Read our review →

Browse the lists this crawl appears in

Scroll to Top

Pick your kind of night

Ghost stories, free shots, or a pint with the history.